Tuesday 5 September 2023

A History Mystery

Hello friends!

I have a little family history mystery which no one in the family can solve. So I put my best thinking cap on and try to work out what it is.

Going through a box of my late mother's belongings, I came across a small brass match case. It is very obviously something from the First World War and has two significant engravings on it out of three sides, all of which are engraved.

The least significant engraving is this one.


The main areas of engraving on this side are a Cross in the centre, which flanked by what appeared to be two oak leaves. There is a crown in the top part of the cross which might point to a regiment, or simply be indicative of the owner being a soldier of the King, and the date 1914 on the opposing side of the cross.  Directly in the middle is a capital letter W.

Let's take a look at the two sides and what's engraved on them. 

The opposite large side has the wording D Williams engraved on a banner across the centre and it is flanked by what appears to be two stylised daffodils.


I will come back to my thoughts and discoveries on this shortly. But first, I will share with you what is engraved on the spine of this book like box.


It is not easy to make out the engraving, because it is highly stylised. However, after much experimenting with letter combinations, I have. discovered it is AUDRUICQ.   Audruicq is a commune in the Pas-de-Calais department in northern France.  

Further research revealed to me that during the First World War it served a
s a transport hub where goods arrived in bulk by ship and were broken down into wagon-loads and sent on by rail
 to the Front.  It was also a centres for collecting, sorting and despatching reinforcements to units in the field.

Now onto the name, which is the most important part.  D. Williams.  I know of only one D Williams in the family.  He was my cousin, the late Rev. David Williams and he most certainly was not born until well after WW1.  In truth, he wasn't old enough to go to the Second World War either. So it's not him. The only evidence of anyone going to the First World War I have on that side of my family is my grandfather J.G. Williams, who also happens to be the grandfather of Rev. David.

So, who is this D. Williams of the matchbox cover?

I have done some basic family research and I find it rather fascinating, but it does draw me in and becomes cost prohibitive by the time you order and pay for all your certificate copies, etc.  Unfortunately, on my mother's father's side, the information I have is scant at best.  Now that there is no one left to ask, as happens with so many other people, I am full of regret for not having asked questions while the relevant people who could provide answers were still alive.

Rev. David and I shared a grandfather, but we had different grandmothers because Dacu {Welsh for Grandfather} was married twice.  

Due to my grandmother being his second wife, I am finding it very difficult to go back further into the family history on that side. All of the history that I have to my fingertips came from my mother and does not contain much information from his first marriage.  I suppose if I really wanted to dig around, I could find the information. However, I did manage to do a little research in which I found out that my grandfather and his younger brother, apparently named David, ended up in the workhouse when they were around 9 and 7 years old respectively. How sad it that?  Orphans and in the work house at such a tender age.  When I learned they had ended up in the workhouse at such a young age, my research came to a grinding halt. I couldn't seem to get past that my grandfather had been in the workhouse from such a young age.

So have I found the D Williams, whose name is engraved on the matchbox? I think perhaps I have. Although scant, the information I have  certainly would make him eligible to be conscripted or able to be a volunteer for the war.

The only thing is this: everybody to whom I have spoken has no recollection of another David Williams, or for that matter, anybody with the initial D {Williams} in the family.  To date, I have not found any record of how or when D. Williams of the matchbox died.  Did he die in France, or did he return home?  My records are scant, and as happens there are many possible candidates on Ancestry and Find My Past with the same initials or names living in the general area.  

Anomalies and errors in the Censuses don't help, nor does the changing street names and construction over the relevant decades.  For example, there are few alive today who know the location of the Reading Room, or that Goat Street was formerly Ship Street, or that Oakley Street was not part of Nun Street as it is today.  Accurate family research is not limited to just censuses. birth certificates, death certificates and marriage certificates.  You have to be prepared to sift through maps and all kinds of other documents and records in order to correctly identify people.  Tithe maps are particularly interesting!  I digress.

I am wondering if my Uncle Billy, {father of Rev David Williams, and son of JG Williams} was the only one who knew of this other D. or David Williams? It is highly possible that he did know of him, and if he did indeed perish in the First World War, maybe Uncle Billy named his first born son after him.

Unless I decide to dig further, or someone in the family discovers something new, I guess we'll never know who D Williams was.  I am about to pass this little piece of history on to my cousin, Rev David's son.  Maybe he will pick up the baton with success?

So my friends,
Until next time
Stay well, Stay safe
Debbie xx

18 comments:

  1. The cross and oak leaves are very reminscent of the German cross, which was alwaysy flanked with 'Eichenlaub' - oak leaves. I would think it might be a German piece. Type 'German cross and oakleaves' and into your browser and then 'pictures' and you will see lots of illustrations. Hope this helps you a little bit. Hugs, Valerie

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you Valerie. Bovey Belle beat me to it and has provided me with a very interesting link. If you look in the comments below, you will see what she sent. and it links to an almost identical cross. A mystery seems to be developing.

      Delete
  2. My goodness Deb, this is a mystery to which you have delved into with the best of your ability. I often wish I had asked certain questions of my parents and grandparents. It is a lesson for us all to ask now! Sending you hugs.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you. If you read the comments that came after yours. one of them has provided a very interesting response. It really does make me wish I'd researched it now when somebody who could have answered questions was alive but I didn't even know of its existence.

      Delete
  3. Like Valerie, it looks like the German Iron cross, and the oakleaves would fit in with that too. In fact, when I looked further, the German Iron Cross has a crown stamped on it! https://www.ima-usa.com/products/original-german-wwi-prussian-vaulted-iron-cross-first-class-1914-marked-800-eki?variant=31686652592197 Now . . . why should D Williams, whoever he may be in your family tree, have that on HIS match case? Perhaps he found it, and the back of it was blank and he put his name on?

    I feel your frustration of not being able to definitively find the D Williams you seek but it does sound like your grandfather's uncle.

    ReplyDelete
  4. What an interesting post and how frustrating you can't find the D Williams in question. I do hope your cousin is able to solve the mystery and help. I also wish I had asked far more questions when people were still with us. Its a lovely little box by the way.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you Caroline as you can. as you can see, Bovey Belle has thrown some very interesting options. into the equation.

      Delete
    2. Yes - just noticed them - interesting :)

      Delete
  5. OK, a bit more research this end. The BEF (British Expeditionary Force) set up camp there in 1914 - it was only 11 miles or so from Calais. The Royal Engineers were the lads involved in this vicinity, so possibly D Williams was one of their number (perhaps this would tie him down a bit?) The area was developed in 1915 and it was known as No. 10 Ordnance Depot, with vast amounts of ammunition stored there. The Army Ordnance Corps and Army Service Corps Labour Companies were involved. Keith says these were stand-alone regiments, so again another place to loo for D Williams. Then in July 1916 there was a gigantic explosion (it was bombed). https://www.longlongtrail.co.uk/battlefields/gazetteer-of-the-western-front/gazetteer-of-the-western-front-audruicq/ Interesting reading, and I hope it helps your research.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you Yes, I have been reading it and plan to go ahead and do a bit more delving, but not too much more as this piece will be passed on to my cousin. along with the baton for doing further research if he so chooses. I'm afraid I'm just far too tired and with my tremors the computer doesn't always want to play ball scrolling up and down.
      Did he loot it as a macabre souvenir from the body of a soldier he killed?? I hope not! Or, if he was in the AOC or similar. then perhaps he didn't go to the Front? Maybe he just happened to know what the cross looked like and copied it? I have no idea, there are so many questions and possibilities.

      Delete
  6. P.S. Keith thinks that your ancestor may have captured someone who had an Iron Cross? Or else killed a German with one.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Although not the most savoury option it does seem to be the most likely. I believe looting was quite. commonplace on the battlefield

      Delete
  7. An interesting read, it would be rather nice if the mystery could be solved.

    All the best Jan

    ReplyDelete
  8. This is so interesting. Just imagine an iteem from WW-I . Hope Rev David's son reallly pursues this.

    ReplyDelete
  9. So many questions. I hope you get the answers at some point. Good Luck~

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This is my comment, Deb. I have no idea why it ended up anonymous. I do hope you get the answers to this mystery.

      Delete
  10. I find genealogy fascinating and have done quite a bit of my own, still having a few mysteries. (You're right about the maps!) And right about the names. I've been trying to find records for an Ann Williams that we THINK was our second great grandmother, who came to the US in 1850 and had my g-grandfather on board ship. We can't even find the ship manifest, much less records of them till he was older. Frustrating. I digress.

    My guess if that you are right -- that the David Williams of conscription age died in France and when his personal things were eventually returned, this was one of them. Somehow it was passed down and you are fortunate enough to be its keeper. I suppose if you could get your hands on Army records of WWI there might be some indication of next of kin or residence that could help.

    I googled British Expeditionary Force match box after reading the comment above. There was a link with a photo very similar to yours. Different, but same deal. https://dracomedals.com/great-britain-united-kingdom-france-trench-art-ww1-matchbox-holder-match-box-patriotic-battle-arras-loos-ypres-mons-marne-aisne-baf-wwi-1914-1917-1918-great-war-british-expeditionary-force-french-ordnance-brass-bronze.html

    Also, the German Iron Cross idea above makes a lot of sense. Possibly yes, had his name engraved or perhaps they were given to those who participated in whichever battle with Germans they may have won? This is a wonderful mystery!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you so much for that link. It's virtually identical, except for the nature of the engravings. Unfortunately, nobody. living seems to have even heard of this David Williams, soldier. I only accidentally came across who I think is him when I was looking for something else. My research is not helped by another family member who's gone off on a very incorrect tangent of research. She has just clutched at the first name that fits. and hasn't looked at the profile at all. That is actually for a different person altogether, though.
      Good luck with your research trying to locate your ancestor. Ann. One thing I have discovered, and you probably have as well. is that the same names occur repeatedly. My maternal great grandmother's name was Mary Ann. You cannot have any idea how many dozens of women there are listed under Mary Ann for the same parish. As it happens I. have a Mary Ann on my father's side as well. It was a very common name. And speaking of my father's side of the family, I. cannot tell you how many people are listed in the census and on their birth certificates under one Christian name. yet were known commonly in the family by a different pet name. It makes research very, very difficult when you're looking for a Connie whose real name is Mary.

      Delete